How to increase online sales: 10 ways for small online stores

How to increase online sales without just buying traffic: 10 steps we see work for small stores, from search to bigger orders, and how to measure each one.

Online sales come from three numbers: how many people visit your store, how many of them buy, and how much each order is worth. To increase online sales, move one of them, measure it, then move the next. Most small stores start by paying for more visitors. In our experience the cheaper wins are usually inside the store: shoppers who search and find nothing, baskets that stop just short of free delivery, and returning customers who see the same homepage as a stranger.

We’ve spent more than ten years helping Shopify, BigCommerce and Magento stores sell more, and this is the order we’d work in.

Start with your numbers

Write these down before you change anything, for the last 4 weeks and the same 4 weeks last year:

  • Sessions: how many visits your store gets.
  • Conversion rate: orders divided by sessions. If 2,000 visits bring 40 orders, it’s 2%.
  • Average order value (AOV): revenue divided by orders.
  • Searches that find nothing: your store’s search report, or your analytics site search report.

Revenue is sessions × conversion rate × AOV. A 10% gain in any one of them is a 10% gain in revenue, so pick the one that’s easiest for your store to move. That’s your online sales strategy for the next month.

Get more of the right visitors

1. Make your category pages worth finding. Shoppers search for “linen shirts” or “MIG welding wire”, not for your brand. Give each important category a clear title, a short paragraph that says what’s in it and who it’s for, and links to the categories around it. Category pages often win these searches over product pages, because they answer a broader question.

2. Put your products where shoppers compare them. Free product listings in Google Shopping only need your product feed, which your platform can usually send to Google Merchant Center. If you advertise, start with Shopping ads for your best sellers and the searches that already convert, and stop anything you can’t measure in orders.

3. Build a list you own. An email list is the one channel no algorithm can take away. Ask for the email at a moment that makes sense, such as for back-in-stock alerts or a first-order offer, and send something useful every month.

Convert more of the visitors you already have

4. Fix search first. Shoppers who search have told you exactly what they want, so a search that finds nothing is the most expensive dead end in your store. Read your searches that find nothing every week. Most are typos, plurals or your shoppers’ own words (“hoodie” when you sell “hooded tops”), and each one is fixed with a synonym. Show products as shoppers type, so most of them never reach a results page at all. This is what we built Instant Search for: it corrects small typos, puts in-stock products first, and lists the searches that find nothing so you can fix them in a click. Our ecommerce site search guide goes further.

5. Show delivery costs early. Surprise costs at checkout are a common reason shoppers give up. Put your delivery price and free-delivery threshold on product pages and in the basket, not just at checkout.

6. Make product pages answer the question. Good photos, the sizes or specifications people ask your team about, honest reviews, and stock levels. If customers email you the same question twice, the answer belongs on the page.

7. Make it quick on a phone. On most stores, most visits come from phones. Open your own store on yours, on mobile data, and buy something. Fix whatever slows you down, starting with large images and apps you no longer use.

Make each order bigger

8. Set a free-delivery threshold just above a typical order, and show it. If your typical order is £38, a £45 threshold gives most shoppers a reason to add one more thing. Show how far each basket has to go, and suggest in-stock items that close the gap. A free-delivery bar across the page does this for every visitor.

9. Offer one more item before they pay. As shoppers head to checkout, show up to three products that go with what’s in the basket, and let them add one without leaving. Checkout Upsell does this on BigCommerce and Shopify, with a free-delivery progress bar, and picks the products for you. Our guide to increasing average order value has seven tactics like this, each with what to measure.

Bring shoppers back

10. Treat returning customers like regulars. Someone on their third visit shouldn’t see the same homepage as someone on their first. Show returning customers what’s new in the categories they buy from, and first-time visitors your best sellers. Personalised banners let you show each group of shoppers something different in the same spot, and product recommendations pick products for each shopper by themselves. Both report the revenue they bring in.

What we see across PureClarity stores

Across more than ten stores from November 2025 to October 2026, the median store had 5.4% of its orders include a product the shopper clicked in PureClarity, such as a recommendation, a personalised banner or Instant Search. Those orders were worth 1.38× the store’s other orders, with 2.4 different products against 1.6. That’s a correlation, not proof that we caused all of it: shoppers who build bigger baskets also browse and click more. But it shows where bigger orders come from.

One client, Engweld, earns 11× its PureClarity fee in revenue from recommended products, and 7.3% of its online orders include one.

Measure every change

Change one thing at a time, and compare the same weeks before and after. Look at the number the change was meant to move (search exits, AOV or conversion rate) and at revenue, not clicks. Where you can, keep a holdout: a small share of visitors who don’t see the change, so you can tell its effect from a good month. It’s how we judge our own features, and it stops you keeping something just because it looks busy.

A 30-day plan for a small store

  • Week 1: write down your numbers, then read your searches that find nothing and fix the top 20 with synonyms or better product titles.
  • Week 2: put your delivery price and threshold on product pages and in the basket, and test buying on your phone.
  • Week 3: add one more item before checkout, and show how far each basket is from free delivery.
  • Week 4: compare the four weeks with the four before, keep what moved revenue, and pick the next number.

Questions we get asked

How can I increase online sales fast?

Start inside the store, because you don’t have to wait for traffic. Fix the searches that find nothing, show delivery costs early, and offer one more item before checkout. All three can be live within a week and show up in the next week’s numbers.

How do I increase sales on my Shopify store?

The same ten steps apply. On Shopify, check your search box first: turn on predictive search or an app that shows products as shoppers type, and read the searches that find nothing. Then set a free-delivery threshold, offer an add-on before checkout, and show returning customers something new. PureClarity’s Shopify app does search, Checkout Upsell and recommendations, with a free trial.

What is the best online sales strategy for a small business?

Pick the cheapest number to move first. For most small stores that’s conversion rate and order value, not traffic: you already pay for the visitors, so selling more to them costs least. Then put what you learn into the categories and campaigns that bring new visitors.

If you’d like a second pair of eyes on your store’s numbers, book a 30-minute call with us. We’ll show you where we’d start.

Start your 14-day free trial

Which platform is your store on?

Every feature in your plan for 14 days. Not sure yet? Book a 30-minute demo and see it on a store like yours.